Associated Press
Thursday, January 28, 1999

The 54-44 roll call by which the Senate rejected a Democratic plan for the closing phase of the impeachment trial.

On this vote, a "yes" vote was a vote in favor of the Democratic plan and a "no" vote was a vote to reject the plan.

Voting "yes" were 44 Democrats and no Republicans. Voting "no" were 54 Republicans and no Democrats. Sens. Barbara Mikulski (D-Md.) and Wayne Allard (R-Colo.) did not vote.

Alabama	Sen. Jeff Sessions (R): No	Sen. Richard Shelby (R): No
Alaska	Sen. Frank Murkowski (R): No	Sen. Ted Stevens (R): No
Arizona	Sen. Jon Kyl (R): No	Sen. John McCain (R): No
Arkansas	Sen. Tim Hutchinson (R): No	Sen. Blanche Lambert Lincoln (D): Yes
California	Sen. Barbara Boxer (D): Yes	Sen. Dianne Feinstein (D): Yes
Colorado	Sen. Wayne Allard (R): Not voting	Sen. Ben Nighthorse Campbell (R): No
Connecticut	Sen. Christopher Dodd (D): Yes	Sen. Joseph Lieberman (D): Yes
Delaware	Sen. Joseph Biden (D): Yes	Sen. William Roth (R): No
Florida	Sen. Bob Graham (D): Yes	Sen. Connie Mack (R): No
Georgia	Sen. Max Cleland (D): Yes	Sen. Paul Coverdell (R): No
Hawaii	Sen. Daniel Akaka (D): Yes	Sen. Daniel Inouye (D): Yes
Idaho	Sen. Larry Craig (R): No	Sen. Mike Crapo (R): No
Illinois	Sen. Richard Durbin (D): Yes	Sen. Peter Fitzgerald (R): No
Indiana	Sen. Evan Bayh (D) Yes	Sen. Richard Lugar (R): No
Iowa	Sen. Charles Grassley (R): No	Sen. Tom Harkin (D): Yes
Kansas	Sen. Sam Brownback (R): No	Sen. Pat Roberts (R): No
Kentucky	Sen. Jim Bunning (R): No	Sen. Mitch McConnell (R): No
Louisiana	Sen. John Breaux (D): Yes	Sen. Mary Landrieu (D): Yes
Maine	Sen. Susan Collins (R): No	Sen. Olympia Snowe (R): No
Maryland	Sen. Barbara Mikulski (D): Not voting	Sen. Paul Sarbanes (D): Yes
Massachusetts	Sen. Edward Kennedy (D): Yes	Sen. John Kerry (D): Yes
Michigan	Sen. Spencer Abraham (R): No	Sen. Carl Levin (D): Yes
Minnesota	Sen. Rod Grams (R): No	Sen. Paul Wellstone (D): Yes
Mississippi	Sen. Thad Cochran (R): No	Sen. Trent Lott (R): No
Missouri	Sen. John Ashcroft (R): No	Sen. Christopher (Kit) Bond (R): No
Montana	Sen. Max Baucus (D): Yes	Sen. Conrad Burns (R): No
Nebraska	Sen. Chuck Hagel (R): No	Sen. Bob Kerrey (D): Yes
Nevada	Sen. Richard Bryan (D): Yes	Sen. Harry Reid (D): Yes
New Hampshire	Sen. Judd Gregg (R): No	Sen. Bob Smith (R): No
New Jersey	Sen. Frank Lautenberg (D): Yes	Sen. Robert Torricelli (D): Yes
New Mexico	Sen. Jeff Bingaman (D): Yes	Sen. Pete Domenici (R): No
New York	Sen. Daniel Patrick Moynihan (D): Yes	Sen. Charles Schumer (D): Yes
North Carolina	Sen. John Edwards (D): Yes	Sen. Jesse Helms (R): No
North Dakota	Sen. Kent Conrad (D): Yes	Sen. Byron Dorgan (D): Yes
Ohio	Sen. Mike DeWine (R): No	Sen. George Voinovich (R): No
Oklahoma	Sen. James Inhofe (R): No	Sen. Don Nickles (R): No
Oregon	Sen. Gordon Smith (R): No	Sen. Ron Wyden (D): Yes
Pennsylvania	Sen. Rick Santorum (R): No	Sen. Arlen Specter (R): No
Rhode Island	Sen. John Chafee (R): No	Sen. Jack Reed (D): Yes
South Carolina	Sen. Ernest "Fritz" Hollings (D): Yes	Sen. Strom Thurmond (R): No
South Dakota	Sen. Thomas Daschle (D): Yes	Sen. Tim Johnson (D): Yes
Tennessee	Sen. Bill Frist (R): No	Sen. Fred Thompson (R): No
Texas	Sen. Phil Gramm (R): No	Sen. Kay Bailey Hutchison (R): No
Utah	Sen. Robert Bennett (R): No	Sen. Orrin Hatch (R): No
Vermont	Sen. James Jeffords (R): No	Sen. Patrick Leahy (D): Yes
Virginia	Sen. Charles Robb (D): Yes	Sen. John Warner (R): No
Washington	Sen. Slade Gorton (R): No	Sen. Patty Murray (D): Yes
West Virginia	Sen. Robert Byrd (D): Yes	Sen. Jay Rockefeller (D): Yes
Wisconsin	Sen. Russell Feingold (D): Yes	Sen. Herb Kohl (D): Yes
Wyoming	Sen. Mike Enzi (R): No	Sen. Craig Thomas (R): No